6 Comments
User's avatar
Phil S's avatar

Love this piece. A call to arms for philosophical historians!

Richard's avatar

Very appropriate for the 250th. In an earlier exchange with you, you convinced me that it was a revolution as well as a secession so I look forward to further exposition. These people wrote stuff and did it well. God help future historians of our time who will have to untangle truth from tweets.

Hugh Myers's avatar

Is "America's Constitutional Mind" a work in progress or did it morph into the two volume series "Political Thought of the American Revolution"? I recently picked up and am enjoying "America's Revolutonary Mind".

Alexander Simonelis's avatar

Thompson brings up some topics that are certainly deserving of treatment by, and even essential to, history and historians. However, there needs to be a clear delineation between history proper (largely facts, ...) and the analysis of history (where judgments, opinions, ... come into play). Just as there is a distinction in newsrooms (which produce "current history") between news and editorial. Blurring or disregarding the line leads to disaster.

Nick Rosado's avatar

Very quick question: what AI service do you use for the voiceover?